CAUSE NO.
A.S.,
Plaintiff,
v.
J.H.,
MC Legacy Holdings, LLC,
C&S Executive, LLC
Defendants.
In the District Court
Harris County, Texas
_____ Judicial District
Plaintiff's Original Petition
To the Honorable Judge of Said Court: Comes now, A.S. (“A.S.” or “Plaintiff”), complaining of and about J.H. (“J.H.” or “Defendant Driver”), MC Legacy Holdings, LLC, (“MC Legacy” or “Defendant Owner”) and C&S Executive, LLC (“C&S Executive” or “Defendant Operator”) (collectively, “Defendants”), files this his Original Petition, and would respectfully show as follows:
I. Discovery Plan Level & Statement of Relief
1.A Level 2 Discovery Plan governs discovery in this suit. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 190.4.
2.Plaintiff seeks monetary relief of over $1,000,000, including damages of any kind, penalties, costs, expenses, pre-judgement interest and attorney fees. See Tex. R. Civ. P. 47(c).
II. Parties and Service
3.Plaintiff A.S. is a current resident of Anderson, Grimes County, Texas.
4.Defendant J.H., upon information and belief, is a Texas resident and may be served at his last known address of , Houston, Texas, or wherever he may be found.
5.Defendant MC Legacy Holdings, LLC may be served via its registered agent R.M. at , Spring, Texas or wherever R.M. may be found. MC Legacy is a domestic limited liability company conducting business in Texas according to Texas Secretary of State records. In those records, MC Legacy identifies R.M. as its registered agent and manager. Upon information and belief, R.M. owns MC Legacy. In its filings with the Texas Secretary of State, MC Legacy identifies its physical business address and its mailing address as , Spring, Texas.
6.Defendant C&S Executive, LLC may be served via its registered agent C.C. at , Spring, Texas or wherever C.C. may be found. C&S is a domestic limited liability company conducting business in Texas according to Texas Secretary of State records. In those records, C&S identifies C.C. as its registered agent and manager. Upon information and belief, C&S is owned by C.C. C&S identifies its physical business address and its mailing address as , Spring, Texas in its filings with the Texas Secretary of State.
III. Jurisdiction and Venue
7.The Court has jurisdiction over this case, and the damages sought are within the jurisdictional limit of this Court. Venue is proper in Harris County, Texas, because all or a substantial part of the events give rise to the cause of action occurred here. Tex. Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code § 15.002(a); see also id. § 15.005 (governing venue in cases involving multiple defendants). Specifically, the vehicle accident giving rise to Plaintiff’s claims occurred in Harris County. Further, MC Legacy’s principal place of business is in Spring, Harris County, Texas.
IV. Factual Background
8.On or about February 10, 2025, Plaintiff A.S. retained Defendant C&S Executive for executive car service. C&S Executive’s employee Defendant J.H., while driving a 2022 Lincoln Nautilus commercial motor vehicle, collected Plaintiff as C&S Executive and J.H.’s passenger. Upon information and belief, MC Legacy and R.M. owned, leased, borrowed, and/or controlled the 2022 Lincoln Nautilus commercial motor vehicle operated by J.H.
9.At all times relevant to this Petition, J.H. drove the motor vehicle in the course and scope of his employment for C&S Executive and C.C., specifically, in the course and scope of providing executive car service to Plaintiff.
10.While transporting Plaintiff, J.H. headed North bound on Hardy Toll Road towards the Hardy Airport Connector at a high rate of speed. But J.H. failed to keep a proper look out and reduce his speed. Thus, as J.H. neared the curve on the Hardy Toll Road towards the Hardy Airport Connector, J.H. lost control of the vehicle and struck the guard rail.
11.Defendants failed to operate the commercial motor vehicle in a safe, prudent manner, resulting in a collision in which Plaintiff sustained serious and incapacitating personal injuries, losses, and damages as a result. This suit is brought in accordance with the laws of the State of Texas for the recovery of damages to which Plaintiff is entitled to recover from Defendants. The Plaintiff will show that the incident was brought about to occur and was proximately caused by the negligence of Defendants.
V. Count One – Negligence Against J.H.
12.Defendant J.H. had a duty to exercise the degree of care that a reasonable careful person would use to avoid harm to others under similar circumstances to those described herein. Plaintiff A.S.’s personal injuries and damages were proximately caused by the negligence and breach of duty of Defendant J.H. in one or more of the following particulars: (a) In operating his vehicle in a careless and reckless manner; (b) In driving in a manner that was unsafe for the conditions present on the roadway; (c) In failing to timely and/or properly apply the brakes of his vehicle in time to avoid a collision; (d) In failing to control his vehicle; (e) In failing to maintain a clear, reasonable, distance from the guard rail; (f) In failing to maintain a safe distance as a reasonable person would have done; (g) In failing to keep a proper lookout; (h) In failing to take timely and/or proper evasive action; (i) In operating a vehicle at a time when J.H. was distracted; (j) In violating state law as to make this defendant negligent per se; (k) In committing various acts and/or omissions of negligence, both statutory and common law, to be specified in detail at the time of trial.
13.Defendant J.H. had common-law and statutory duties to use ordinary care in the operation of the motor vehicle. Defendant negligently breached those duties and proximately caused Plaintiff’s injuries and damages. The acts of negligence as set out above were a proximate cause of the collision(s) made the basis of this lawsuit. Plaintiff reserves his right to amend these allegations as further facts, investigation and discovery may warrant.
VI. Count Two – Negligence Against MC Legacy Holdings, LLC
14.Defendant MC Legacy, by and through their registered agent R.M., and their employees were negligent on the occasion in question and proximately caused Plaintiff’s injuries and damages by: (a) Failing to properly investigate Defendant J.H. before employing J.H.; (b) Failing to property train and/or supervise Defendant J.H.; and (c) Failing to observe the appropriate standard of care by entrusting the motor vehicle to Defendant J.H., who MC Legacy knew, or in the exercise of ordinary care should have known, was a reckless driver, incompetent driver, or was otherwise unfit or unqualified to drive and operate the vehicle in question.
15.Each and every of the above collectively and/or singularly were a proximate cause of the collision in question and the resulting injuries and damages to Plaintiff.
VII. Count Three – Negligence Against C&S Executive, LLC
16.Defendant C&S Executive, by and through their registered agent C.C., and their employees were negligent on the occasion in question and proximately caused Plaintiff’s injuries and damages by: (a) Failing to properly investigate J.H.; (b) Failing to property train and/or supervise J.H.; and (c) Failing to observe the appropriate standard of care by entrusting the motor vehicle to Defendant J.H., who C&S Executive knew, or in the exercise of ordinary care should have known, was a reckless driver, incompetent driver, or was otherwise unfit or unqualified to drive and operate the vehicle in question.
17.Each and every of the above collectively and/or singularly were a proximate cause of the collision in question and the resulting injuries and damage to Plaintiff.
VIII. Count Four – Vicarious Liability Imputed Against MC Legacy Holdings, LLC & C&S Executive, LLC
18.Defendants MC Legacy and C&S Executive are vicariously liable for the negligence of Defendant J.H., under the theory respondent superior as, at all times material, J.H. was employed by Defendants MC Legacy and C&S Executive, and J.H. was acting within the course and scope of said employment, and in furtherance of said Defendants’ business, at the time of the collision made the basis of this lawsuit. Further, the Plaintiff would show that at all times material, J.H. was the statutory employee of Defendants MC Legacy and C&S Executive pursuant to the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations.
IX. Damages of Plaintiff
19.Plaintiff would show that as a direct and proximate result of the Defendants’ negligence and wrongful conduct, she has suffered serious and disabling injuries. As a result of these injuries, Plaintiff has and will suffer: (a) Reasonable and necessary medical care and expenses in the past for the treatment of his injuries; (b) Reasonable and necessary medical and psychological care and expenses which will in all reasonable probability be incurred in the future for the treatment of his injuries; (c) Physical pain in suffering in the past and future; (d) Plaintiff has suffered a loss of enjoyment of life as a result of the injuries incurred and will continue to suffer loss and enjoyment of life in the future; (e) Physical impairment suffered in the past and which will in all reasonable probability be suffered in the future; (f) The loss of earning, household services, fringe benefits in the past and the disability from which Plaintiff now suffers and will in all reasonable medical probability continue to suffer from for the rest of his life; (g) Mental anguish suffered in the past and which will in all reasonable probability be suffered in the future; (h) Plaintiff further seeks the recovery of all interest allowed by law, including pre-judgment and post-judgment interest.
X. Punitive/Exemplary Damages
20.The above-stated actions and/or omissions of Defendants J.H., MC Legacy, and C&S Executive constitute more than ordinary negligence. They are of such nature so as to constitute gross negligence and to further and otherwise justify and require the imposition of punitive and exemplary damages against Defendants. Plaintiff hereby sues for recovery of such damages.
XI. Conditions Precedent
21.All conditions precedent to Plaintiff’s claims for relief have been performed or have occurred.
XII. Rule 193.7 Notice
22.Defendants are hereby notified that Plaintiff intends to use all documents produced by Defendants in discovery at the trial of this cause and therefore request that Defendants assert any objection to the authenticity of any document Defendants produce within ten days of its production.
XIII. Jury Demand
23.Plaintiff herby respectfully requests a trial by jury.
Prayer
WHEREFORE, PREMISES CONSIDERED, Plaintiff A.S. respectfully prays that all named Defendants J.H., MC Legacy Holdings, LLC, and R.M., R.M., and C&S Executive, LLC be cited to appear and answer herein, and that upon a final hearing of the cause, judgement be entered for the Plaintiff against Defendants for all damages requested hereinabove, in an amount in excess of the minimum jurisdictional limits of the Court, and any such other and further relief to which Plaintiff may be entitled at law or in equity, whether pled or unpled.
Respectfully submitted,
JDA Trials LLC
/s/ Jeffrey D. Anderson
Jeffrey D. Anderson
State Bar No. 24087100
Attorney for Plaintiff
Redacted public copy prepared by JDA Trials · Allegations are not findings · Not legal advice